Rock Solid: How the Philippines Won Its Maritime Case against China.

AuthorCook, Malcolm
PositionBook review

Rock Solid: How the Philippines Won Its Maritime Case against China. By Marites Dafiguilan Vitug. Quezon City, Metro Manila: BUGHAW. Softcover: 315pp.

The main title of Marites Vitug's account of the Philippines' maritime rights case against China does this book justice. The Philippine case against China was rock solid and the Philippines won a comprehensive legal victory on 16 July 2016. Vitug's book itself, at the risk of a bad pun, is also rock solid. It is an authoritative account, with lots of colour and character, of the history of the maritime rights dispute between the Philippines and China in the South China Sea, the decision by President Benigno Aquino to take China to court in 2013 and how the case itself unfolded.

The book's subtitle though does not do the book justice. Certainly, using access and interview skills as one of the Philippines' leading investigative journalists, Vitug provides a compelling account of how the Philippines won the case. However the structure of the book allows it to do much more than the title claims.

The first part looks at the history of the bilateral dispute from the Philippine standpoint going back to 1968. This part, which takes up about a third of the book, shows how China's approach to its claims in the South China Sea has been very consistent. International maritime law and the desire for good relations with the Philippines have not influenced this maximalist approach. On the other hand, different Philippine administrations, and different key actors within those administrations, have taken very different approaches to the dispute with China.

The author effectively shows that the desire for cordial and economically beneficial relations with China was a strong motivating factor for President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo to take a softer approach to the dispute with China. Jose Almonte's suggestion on page 18 that during the administration of President Fidel Ramos, Foreign Secretary Domingo Siazon's opposition to a planned Philippine Navy mission to Scarborough Shoal may have been influenced by his eagerness to gain China's support for his bid to become UN Secretary General, shows that the desire for good relations with Asia's most powerful country can serve personal interests as well. The first part of the book also clearly shows that China's claims to Scarborough Shoal, its interest in Reed Bank and its military plans for Mischief Reef were longstanding positions and not a response to the Obama...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT