The Four Flashpoints: How Asia Goes to War.

AuthorBateman, Sam
PositionBook review

The Four Flashpoints: How Asia Goes to War. By Brendan Taylor. Melbourne, Australia: La Trobe University Press, 2018. Softcover: 241pp.

The flashpoints of Asia are well-known: the Korean Peninsula, the East China Sea, the South China Sea and Taiwan. All four are characterized by simmering tensions and the potential to erupt into conflict with widespread, and potentially catastrophic, consequences. There are ample books and commentaries dealing with each flashpoint, but Brendan Taylor goes further by painting a broader picture of how these four issues are collectively worsening Asia's strategic environment. Taylor sketches how tensions could play out in each flashpoint and argues that crises can only be avoided by understanding the complex relations between them. He suggests that a major war in Asia is more likely than most would assume, as the region is in the throes of a "crisis slide" (p. 177) where the cumulative pressure of the four flashpoints is pushing it closer to conflict.

An appealing part of Taylor's book is his description of the historical background to each dispute. He combines this with comprehensive research of the current situation, along with his first-hand expertise of the region, to produce what is basically a pessimistic assessment of where Asia is heading.

Taylor identifies four reasons why the flashpoints are more threatening to global order than regional rivalries elsewhere. The first is the capacity of regional states to wage war with their burgeoning defence budgets and simmering security dilemmas. Secondly, there is the centrality of Asia to the global economy and information and trade flows. Thirdly, regional inexperience in dealing with tensions and managing conflict increases the risks of an accidental war. In addition, the multilateral security framework necessary to effectively manage the risks of stumbling into a conflict is still missing. Lastly, the powerful forces of history and nationalism are increasingly evident in Asia. These forces are apparent in all four flashpoints.

The book deals with the Korean Peninsula first. This has attracted much attention recently with on again, off again predictions of conflict, the Trump administration's inconsistent policies, and North Korean dictator Kim Jong-un's game plays. It is what Taylor refers to as a "Mexican stand-off" (p. 58), a situation not conducive to a speedy solution.

Taylor then turns to the dispute in the East China Sea over the Senkaku/Diaoyu...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT